Williamsport Local

Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Cheap Eats in Williamsport

Updated October 2026 · 7 places · Williamsport

Quick answer

Our top picks are Harvest Moon, Mr. Sticky’s and Lucky Strike Diner.

Here are eight options at addresses within Williamsport, Pennsylvania. The list favors locally based restaurants and uses official business pages for addresses and descriptions; prices are included only where a source states them, so check the current menu for other dishes before you go.

Editorial illustration: Cheap Eats in Williamsport

The list

  1. 1

    Harvest Moon

    535 Arch Street, Williamsport, PA 17701

    Harvest Moon is a family-owned restaurant and convenience store serving homestyle breakfast, lunch, and dinner. It is known for waffles, omelets, and Oreo Crusted Stuffed French Toast; its site lists sandwiches and sides, with sandwich choices served with fries or other sides.

    Best for: homestyle breakfast and sandwiches

    WebsiteDirections
  2. 2

    Mr. Sticky’s

    1948 E. Third Street, Williamsport, PA 17701

    Mr. Sticky’s is a bakery and restaurant in Williamsport. It specializes in homemade sticky buns and also serves sandwiches on homemade rolls, soups, and salads.

    Best for: sticky buns and sandwiches

    WebsiteDirections
  3. 3

    Lucky Strike Diner

    1229 W. Fourth Street, Suite B, Williamsport, PA 17701

    Lucky Strike Diner serves homestyle breakfast and lunch. Its website identifies it as a breakfast-and-lunch restaurant at its Williamsport address.

    Best for: breakfast and lunch

    WebsiteDirections
  4. 4

    Old School Pizza

    $ · 12 E. Fourth Street, Williamsport, PA 17701

    Old School Pizza is a pizzeria serving hand-tossed pizza made with its signature homemade sauce and freshly sliced mozzarella. Its menu lists pizza by the slice for $1 and several small pies for less than $15.

    Best for: pizza by the slice

    WebsiteDirections
  5. 5

    Vinnie’s Italian Eatery

    44 W. Fourth Street, Williamsport, PA 17701

    Vinnie’s Italian Eatery serves lunch and dinner in Williamsport. Its website lists pizza, sandwiches, wings, lasagna, ravioli, and other Italian dishes among its specialties.

    Best for: pizza and Italian-American dishes

    WebsiteDirections
  6. 6

    Windows on 4th

    $ · 200 W. Fourth Street, Williamsport, PA 17701

    Windows on 4th is a restaurant and bar inside the Historic Genetti Hotel. Its listed menu includes a $15 build-your-own burger and a $15 cheesesteak.

    Best for: burgers and sandwiches

    Directions
  7. 7

    Williamsport restaurant listing at 135 West Third Street

    135 W. Third Street, Williamsport, PA 17701

    The Williamsport dining listing identifies this restaurant at 135 West Third Street. The available listing confirms the address but does not provide a specific specialty or menu price, so verify the current menu before visiting.

    Best for: breakfast

    Directions
← Browse all guides