Best Pizza in Williamsport
Updated October 2026 · 8 places · Williamsport
These locally rooted pizzerias are physically located in Williamsport, Pennsylvania; nearby Loyalsock Township and South Williamsport locations are excluded. Addresses, websites and descriptions are drawn from restaurant pages and review or local-coverage sources; operating status is supported by current listings or business information.
Map coming soon
Our Picks
The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza & Pasteria
343 Pine St., Suite 2, Williamsport, PA 17701
The Stonehouse is a wood-fired pizza and Italian restaurant in Pine Square. Reviewers describe its pizza and Italian dishes favorably, and its wood-fired cooking is a defining feature.
Bart’s Pizzeria
536 W. 3rd St., Williamsport, PA 17701
Bart’s is a local pizzeria serving thin-crust pizza, slices and other pizza-shop fare. Reviews particularly describe its crust as very thin and crisp, with sauce that complements rather than overwhelms it.
Venice Pizza Shop
1875 E. 3rd St., Williamsport, PA 17701
Venice Pizza Shop is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Reviewers praise its pizza and value, and a local review listing notes the balance of crust and cheese.
Long Island Pizza
435 Hepburn St., Williamsport, PA 17701
Long Island Pizza is a neighborhood pizzeria serving pizza and other casual fare. Reviewers call out its specialty slices, including buffalo-chicken and cheesesteak-and-pepperoni, and praise the crust.
Vinnie’s Italian Eatery
44 W. 4th St., Williamsport, PA 17701
Vinnie’s Italian Eatery is an Italian restaurant on West Fourth Street that has served the area for decades. Its own site describes its pizza as freshly made with a lightly crisp bottom, while Tripadvisor reviewers also single out its stromboli.
Old School Pizza
12 E. 4th St., Williamsport, PA 17701
Old School Pizza is a pizzeria at 12 East Fourth Street, with hours listed on its own site extending to midnight. Review listings describe customers ordering its pizzas regularly and praise the pizza’s traditional style.
Joe’s Pizza West End
967 W. 3rd St., Williamsport, PA 17701
Joe’s Pizza West End is the Williamsport branch of a local pizza-and-sandwich business, located beside Penn College. Reviewers describe the pizza and cheesesteaks as among the best in town.
Park Pizza
1701 Memorial Ave., Williamsport, PA 17701
Park Pizza is a locally operated pizzeria serving pizza, wings and stromboli. Local listings identify white pizza and stromboli among its offerings, and reviewers describe it as a family-owned business with a long history serving Williamsport.